Writer, Editor, Photographer

TMI — Too Much Information

I consume a lot of information. Too much, really. After many failed information diets, I’ve decided to try to curate instead of quit. Inspired by sites like Longreads, I seek the best and the most memorable writing the web has to offer.

Delivering health care on US$19 per capita (CMAJ)

August 15, 2012, Mason0 Comments
CMAJ health care on $US19
By Christopher Mason

Kampala, Uganda

Walking through the corridors of Uganda’s largest hospital, Mulago, in Kampala, it is clear that standard yardsticks used to measure a country’s health care system do not tell the full story.

Spending figures and patient wait times do not explain how a health care system functions when its largest, and best equipped, hospital’s maternity ward is so full that women frequently give birth on the floor — this being the case when, to begin with, only 13% of the country’s mothers give birth in a hospital.

By Western standards, the system is almost unfathomable. Without access to equipment and technology typically found in hospitals throughout Europe and North America, the diagnosis is largely symptom driven. Doctors and medical students must rely on decades-old textbooks for medical knowledge.

That they are able to achieve any measure of success, in a country that is 1 of the world’s poorest and has an extremely dispersed population, is often a testimony to their ingenuity and to the substantial financial support provided by the international community, which covers about two-thirds of the health budget.

The country’s Ministry of Health projects that it would need about 16% of the government’s budget to be spent on health for the system to function properly. Although spending once reached 10%, it now fluctuates between 7 and 9%.

“The health care system is under-funded,” says Dr. Sam Okware, Uganda’s commissioner of Health Services. “Unless [16% is achieved], it will be hard for us to operate.”

The system also faces instability from conflict in the north, sporadic flooding and other conditions (malaria, HIV/AIDs, malnutrition) common to countries throughout Africa, as well as relatively unique disease challenges like a recent regional Ebola outbreak.

“In such times we have no choice but to use what is existing and replace it later when we can,” Okware says.

When floods displaced hundreds of thousands in eastern Uganda in September, aid workers and local health officials struggled to contain malaria outbreaks and feared a cholera epidemic. In many villages, residents moved into schools and health centres because they were the only structures in the community with concrete floors that would allow people to escape the soggy muddy ground on which they would otherwise be forced to sleep.

This was the case in Ngariam, a small village about a 10-hour drive northeast of Kampala that had been established to protect area farmers from cattle raids conducted by tribes to the north. The community has a well-constructed health centre meant to give locals access to basic medicines and care.

At the height of the flooding, when so many were sick, it was full only with the belongings of those who had flocked to it for shelter because they didn’t have the means to get to the next largest town, 10 km away. The centre’s shelves were empty, and had been that way for weeks.

“Here we have a situation where we have no medicine, when we’re at risk of an outbreak of malaria, dysentery, cholera, or any of the viruses people can get during heavy flooding,” said Ariko Thadeo, a clinical officer in charge of the Ngariam Health Centre.

The Ugandan Ministry of Health says it needs US$4 per person per year to adequately deliver drugs to its citizens. Instead, they get about US$1.67 per person per year.

There is typically a wide gap between health care services in the country’s rural areas, such as Ngariam, and those in urban areas like the capital city Kampala. But an overall investment shortage leaves little resources for medicines, training and equipment.

According to the World Health Organization, the Ugandan government invests about US$19 per capita on health, compared with Canada’s US$3037. Generally, the physical infrastructure of health centres and hospitals is adequate, but there’s a lack of investment in services and personnel (Box 1). There is, in particular, a dearth of trained professionals to treat patients, which forces everyone to seek novel solutions.

“Health care workers have to be innovative when they have so few resources,” says Apollo Dalton Nyangasi, chairman of the Uganda Medical Workers Union.

Most doctors are trained at Kampala’s Makerere University, 1 of 3 medical schools in the country. Students at Makerere attend 5 years of classes, followed by 1 year of full-time work at Mulago Hospital. During that latter year, they are expected to toil 7 days a week for 12 months, all unpaid, which makes it extremely difficult for children from poor families to attend medical school.

Remarkably, despite the obstacles, funding shortfalls and challenges, there are success stories.

In the north, where rebels waged a 20-year civil war against the Ugandan government until peace was negotiated last year, immunization rates and overall health education among the population is very high.

This is mostly because many of the north’s 4.5 million people lived in displaced persons’ camps, some for parts or all of the 2 decade duration of the conflict. As such, international organizations had a centralized, captive audience to treat and educate on health concerns.

As people begin moving home, the Ugandan government has given 25% more funding to northern districts to help the region’s health care system adjust to the changing environment.

Uganda is also often held up as an HIV/AIDS success story.

Having been 1 of the first countries to face an AIDS epidemic, it was also 1 of the first to respond with a coordinated campaign of education and testing.

Numbers vary, but it is generally held that Uganda’s HIV/AIDS infections peaked in 1991, when about 15% of the population was infected. Today, less than 7% is said to be infected and there continue to be large-scale campaigns encouraging abstinence, condom use and faithfulness in marriage as ways to bring the number further down.
Published January 2008 by the Canadian Medical Association Journal

Photo credit: Christopher Mason

Link to article

Leave a Reply